My Coaching Experiment
Do you ever look forward to someone's content?
I do, there are about a dozen people that I'm connected to that tend to get me thinking. This is the kind of content that I like. The challenging stuff.
The articles, tweets and research that makes me stop and think "Hang on, what am I missing".
One of these connections is Tim @tfoleylife. I'd recommend his blog to anyone but it's his tweets that get me. They're short and sweet but for some reason, they really hit home. I think maybe its because they make me really think about what I do as a coach and how I approach "teaching the game".
Here's and example:
If you think life is competitive you will mimic but if you see life as creative, you will be original.
I've never heard that before and have no idea where it comes from but it rings true to me. Not that "truth" seems to carry much weight with Tim.
Uncertainty is the foundation of every life. How you deal with it explains who you are.
Tim embraces uncertainty, knows that uncertainty is certain and importantly has learned to not fear it.
This is what really grabbed me. For decades, I'd been looking for certainty in my coaching. Searching for a methodology that made sense, felt authentic and produced results. This search took me from "teach them how I was taught" to " This feels wrong, what else is there?" to "what do others do?" to " what does the research say?" and then finally to "what is most me?". What is it I can offer, what do I feel is important and am I clear on that?
Years of questioning had brought me to a simple conclusion. I literally had no way of describing my methods as more successful than anyone else's. What I was providing was indeed uncertain.
What I'd also discovered was that so much of the certainty of our methods are wrapped up in our Identity. So, when I was coaching amateur adult teams in the way I'd always been coached, my identity supported this. Why would I not feel that what I was doing was effective.
And yet, when I then started FA Learning, my identity altered and why wouldn't I think that these slightly different methods were most effective?
Then later still, as I started to dig into Ecological Dynamics, why wouldn't I think these methods are effective?
If you're investing time in methods and not trying to debunk them, surely you would see them as effective?
However, up steps Tim again:
When the problem becomes your identity, you'll do almost anything to hold on to it.
This makes it obvious to me why the PJDM practitioner would be so wedded to their methods, why the A Level coach would hold tight to their way of doing thigs. These methods are part of us. We are wedded. We are inseparable.
The thing is, the uncertainty still exists. You can be as wedded to your methods as you wish, but deep down they are methods, whose results, you can't possibly replicate all the time every time and if you can't then how can we be so wedded?
It seems to me, that most of the time ALL the methods fail.
If you are being truly honest with yourself, uncertainty is the only certainty.
Next, I need to introduce you to Dave.
Dave is an old school friend that now lives in Hong Kong. We recently had the chance to catch up and he was interested to hear about my football coaching. As this was over a few beers, the conversation was long and winding.
Dave seemed to realise that I could become frustrated with the uncertainty I've highlighted above. Not being a coach and having no particular axe to grind made it easy for Dave to say " Just don't bother ". He also seemed to understand that this flippant response wasn't going to be enough.
"Look, there's no issue with researching approaches, choosing methodologies and planning your sessions but it's not the be all and end all."
Dave and myself had bonded at school over our eclectic taste in music. We listened to and watched any band we could. Dave played guitar and I played drums and loved recording on my Fostex 4 track. We would record for endless hours, by ourselves or with other fledgling musicians. Sometimes we'd plan the session intricately and sometimes we'd just jam away.
Sometimes though, and here comes the blinding flash, sometimes we'd 100% throw ourselves into the hands of fate. Regardless of what we knew, and what we thought we wanted to do, it could get frustrating. So every now and then we'd just give up trying to fight it.
We were doing this aged 17 & 18 because we'd heard that Brian Eno sometimes recorded this way. He'd devised a set of strategies that he would use to break a creative impasse or just to send the session in a different direction.
He'd published these strategies as a set of cards. We couldn't afford them and the originals are collectors items now but this is what Dave was thinking when he Said " Just don't bother".
It's not about not caring, It's about trusting yourself to let go. Whatever strategy the card throws up, you do it.

This is the context that led me to My Coaching Experiment.
If I was to be honest with myself as a extremely interested, lowly qualified coaching practitioner I had no way at all of demonstrating the certainty that others find. All the research I'd done had led not to certainty but to more questions. None of which is a bad thing.
So, with football slowly opening back up and my team chomping at the bit, I wondered if our teenage homage to Eno could transfer to Football Coaching.
Unfortunately, I could only remember a couple of the strategies that we had copied from Eno's cards onto a set of library index cards we had "borrowed" from school. It's at times like this that I wish I was a hoarder but neither Dave nor I could remember what had happened to them.
What could I remember?
Something about a caterpillar (useless)
Reverse
How would someone else do it?
I also remember something about "delete it all" but only because of a story from the recording of The Joshua tree.
Eno's Oblique Strategies have around 100 cards now so 4 was never going to be enough.
Luckily, there's an app!
Reviewing the Strategies was like one of those smells that drops you right back into a very specific time and place. Memories flooded back.
Unfortunately, few if any of the strategies seemed to be relevant for coaching. Although this is actually the point of the cards, and a user should make of them what they will, I decided to get to work adapting them for a Sports Coach. Some of them became more concrete with specific methods being offered up. Other's stayed just as esoteric, to be defined only by the individual.
As the first sessions came closer I had about 30 strategies that I felt I could rely upon. The Under 14's would be the unknowing recipients of my surrender to fate.
Putting the strategies together was actually much easier than working out how the hell I should use them.
So, for starters I just sat down as normal to think about the first session back and jot down some notes. Here was my opportunity to reach for the cards. Here we go...but hang on, how many should I use?
Do I just draw one and see where that leads me or should I draw a few like a Tarot Reading from Mystic Meg?
I drew just one strategy:

Crap, they've been locked down for 3 months and now I'm going to bore them to death.
My notes were:
Go easy
Let them socialise safely
Carry over theme from before lockdown ( which was through-balls )
So, I set up a nice S&C with them running onto a pass to make a through ball between two mannequins into a bazooka goal. A bit of running at 50%, a couple of jumps and a couple of poles to slalom through. Run on to the pass and play it through.
Any normal coach would now be using their knowledge and experience to think about the myriad of ways that this should be part of a larger session, maybe a Whole-Part-Whole or thinking about Progressions but I was (hesitantly) in the hands of the already chosen strategy.
So we did just that. Just that one exercise for a whole hour with loads of breaks for them to have a drink and chat.
I have no idea if it was more effective than other sessions I've run but that's the whole point. I can't be certain about those things anyway.
What I do know though is I had less to set up, less to worry about and I could focus on how the players were dealing with the important repetition. I was more relaxed and focused on connecting with the players; not worrying about what needs setting up next.
As it was the first session back I think I may have fallen lucky. The kids and parents seemed happy with a gentle reintroduction to training. Nearly two months on though and I've had 3 requests to rerun that very session. Interestingly, there wasn't even a big game.
Dave was right, research and planning is not the be all and end all.
As the experiment progressed, I used the cards in a number of different ways. Some weeks, I've actually planned just as I normally do. One week this was because I wanted to and one week it was because I drew this strategy:

Sometimes, drawing one strategy somehow leads to you wanting to draw another. This can lead to interesting combinations that do all your planning for you. This combination came up 3 weeks in:
Just three strategies drawn a couple of days before the session informed everything. Notice that Peer to Peer feedback is recognised coaching methodology. Would I have included it if I'd planned traditionally? Possibly, but this forces me to experience things that I may not be comfortable with.
On a couple of occasions I've purposefully sat down and used the strategies to plan the session. I drew until I had enough that had built the whole session for me. When I did this, I also disregarded strategies that didn't fit with the feel of preceding ones.
Some of the strategies have been a huge challenge, for instance:

Initially this led to some conflict that I felt I needed to manage. The unbriefed team felt excluded. But maybe that's the point? Maybe a small part of a session that makes them feel uncomfortable could lead to great things?
I had to reign in my desire to explain things here. Plus, how stupid would " Look, just go with it, it came up on some cards" sound to a 13 year old?
If you draw it and don't disregard it, go with it. Trust the strategy and enjoy the ride.
The worst strategy to come out was:

Teenagers can be brutal and they get used to our behaviour. In fact, some turn up expecting us to be a certain way. It's also bloody difficult for some people to behave extravagantly.
I decided an Hawaiian Shirt covered extravagant and I thought I'd got away with it only to be met with Hi Lilo, where's Stich?
My favourite strategy that came out was a one card draw.

This was lovely. I genuinely thought I did quite well at making sure I spoke to everyone but suddenly realised that I gravitate to some rather than others and that some are great at hogging the attention.
Singling out 2 players led to a couple of chats I would never have got to if the card had not decreed it.
So I've used the cards in a number of different ways. Although I've not done this yet, I'm pretty sure they could be used in "real time" with strategies being drawn mid session or really interestingly with the players choosing.
I now have around 50 strategies that I keep shaping and clarifying.
I'm aware that for some coaches this idea would bring them out in cold sweats. In fact, I'm sure some would say this goes against their whole impression of what coaching is. This is my experience, my impression and is borne out of the above context.
I also don't use it all the time and am unsure how it will progress but its been a fantastic couple of months that have challenged me personally and changed the football sessions the players are turning up to.
It's clarified my frustrations about uncertainty and allowed me to compartmentalise research so that my development and learning is kept separate from the practicalities of running a session. I still read and watch as much as I can so I become a better informed coached but the strategies allow me to detach my identity from that information. I don't really want to be defined by any particular way of doing things and I certainly don't want my sessions to be defined in such narrow ways.
Finally, it's taught me that we can experiment with sessions. We can challenge ourselves as much as we challenge our players. We can muck about and enjoy the time and we should do.
As Tim would say:
The only rules that apply are the ones you accept.




Comments